Trade-In Program

  • 🛍️ What We Take

    We accept:

    • Magic: The Gathering
    • Pokémon TCG
    • Yu-Gi-Oh!
    • Star Wars: Unlimited
    • Lorcana
    • Warhammer figures
    • Some accessories and other TCG items (ask staff!)

    ---

    We do not currently accept sports cards, non-TCG collectibles, or graded cards.

  • 💵 What You Get

    Standard Rates (All Days):

    • 60% in Store Credit
    • 40% in Cash

    Bonus Trade-In Days (Tuesdays & Thursdays):

    • 70% in Store Credit
    • 50% in Cash

    ---

    Choose the option that works best for you! Store credit can be used immediately or saved for a future purchase.

📝 How It Works

Bring Your Cards In

Stop by either location during business hours. You’ll be asked to fill out a short trade-in form with your name and contact info.

  • If your trade is small and we’re not busy, we might process it on the spot.
  • For larger trades or during peak hours, we’ll hang onto your trade and process it within 24–48 hours.

Evaluation Process

We’ll go through your cards using current TCGplayer market low pricing and assess card condition.

  • We won’t accept heavily damaged, fake, or non-English cards.
  • Cards under $1.25 in value will be considered bulk (and priced by weight)
  • You can always ask questions or request specific cards back.

Get Paid

Once everything’s approved, we’ll contact you.

  • If you choose store credit, it’ll be applied to your account.
  • If you choose cash, we may schedule pickup depending on the amount.
  • You’ll sign to confirm the trade is complete.

Have Questions?

Not sure if your cards qualify? Curious what your collection might be worth?
Call us, send a message, or stop by—we’re happy to help.